"While Russia has suffered up to 200,000 casualties since its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, a significant minority of these have been due to non-combat causes," the ministry said on Twitter. This screen grab taken from an undated video posted on the Telegram channel @concordgroup_official on 3 April shows Yevgeny Prigozhin, head of Russias Wagner paramilitary group, holding a Russian flag in an undisclosed location. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is to make an official visit to Warsaw on Wednesday, said Poland, announcing a trip. Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba commented on the aid package ahead of a meeting with U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken at NATO headquarters in Brussels. Rounding out the parties entering the new parliament are the Movement for Rights and Freedoms, a center-right party representing ethnic Turks and other Muslims; the Bulgarian Socialist Party; and the populist There Is Such a People party. The laid-off oil workers demanded jobs with the gas giant OzenMunaiGas and continued their demonstration into the morning of April 5. After Lukashenka was declared the winner in the first round, handing him a sixth-straight term in office, opposition leaders claimed the balloting was rigged and that Lukashenka's main rival, Svyatlana Tsikhanouskaya, was the rightful winner. The U.S. Army takes as a rule of thumb that 30% losses are enough to effectively destroy a BTG, but commanders will rotate units and take them out of the line of battle to prevent any given BTG falling apart where possible. But What It Really Wants Is F-16s. But the actual casualty figures are stunning. Belarusian authorities shut down the Union of Poles in Belarus, which Borys headed, after accusing Poland of trying to foment an uprising against authoritarian ruler Alyaksandr Lukashenka. Destroyed equipment includes: 306 fighter, attack, bomber, In early February, the Ukrainian president held talks in London and Paris before traveling on to a special EU summit in Brussels. Russia's announcement that it will station tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus shows that a Russia-China joint statement days earlier amounted to "empty promises," NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said. Russia's National Anti-Terrorism Committee also said that Ukrainian intelligence had been aided in the Tatarsky killing by "agents" from the Anti-Corruption Fund, a banned campaign group set up by jailed Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny. Parliament Speaker Alen Simonian claimed on April 3 that Pashinian had been attacked, alleging that it was part of a series of organized provocations that could be traced to outside the country. Back in 2016, Russian Defense Minister Sergey Shoygu claimed that his tank units had a serviceability rate of 94%, indicating that proportion would be ready to fight on any given day. The mothers made their appeal outside the government building in Zhanaozen. The Russian army as a whole could generate perhaps 160 BTGs in total, so 120 75% of the complete force is perhaps the largest expeditionary force that could be assembled, and this assessment has not been seriously challenged. 10 Pasha Kashchuk poses with a captured Russian vehicle and samurai sword in the Kharkiv region. Thousands of Russian and Ukrainian soldiers have died in the fight for control of the city - and it's thought Russian losses have been far higher than Ukraine's. Invading Russian forces have lost an estimated 2,600 combat soldiers in less than one week as the country struggles to retain its foothold in Ukraine. Russian forces also launched an unsuccessful assault on Bohdanivka in the Donetsk region, the military said. 25K. The ventilators were purchased in April 2020 immediately after a state of emergency was declared in Bosnia amid the pandemic. The new posters did, however, include Olga Buzava, who traveled to Russian occupied areas of Ukraine's Donetsk region to support Russian troops in 2022. The Russian army, supported by the Wagner group, has pressed hard to surround Bakhmuthoping to claim a battlefield victory after a string of humiliating reversals. Thousands were detained in a brutal and sometimes violent crackdown and there have been credible reports of torture and ill-treatment of detainees by security forces. Vladlen Tatarsky, whose real name was Maxim Fomin, was killed in a bomb blast at a cafe in St. Petersburg, Russia's second largest city, on Sunday. The appeal said that many local men are afraid to approach government employment offices for work, and that those who do are often required to speak Russian. Surrogate baby is dead son's, says Spanish TV star, Cybercrime site shut down in global police raids, Deadly cobra in cockpit forces plane to land. According to Oryx, Russia has also lost 53 aircraft, 51 of which were destroyed, and 49 The precise composition of these units may vary, but generally they comprise a large number of armoured vehicles but relatively few infantry troops. Habeck, who is also Germany's economy minister, said investment decisions had either already been made, or were due to be made. "If she wants to give an account of her actions, she can do so in The Hague.". We Continue the Change -- Democratic Bulgaria has already said it would not support a government that includes GERB, which through its victory earned the first chance to form a government. We don't forget about you! Jasina said. They are assisted by one platoon of three vehicles armed with automatic grenade launchers, and another support platoon with five anti-tank vehicles. The Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan worsened an already major humanitarian crisis and triggered an economic meltdown. We hope that similar decisions will be made in relation to Andrzej Poczobut and other prisoners. He faces up to four years in prison if found guilty. Russian tycoon Oleg Deripaska was cleared of contempt of court by Londons High Court in a long-running legal battle with his former business partner. The British Defense Ministry said in its daily intelligence update on April 2 that alcohol abuse was among the noncombat causes of many deaths among Russian troops deployed in Ukraine. However, Borisov said he would not rule out talks with any of the six political bodies that will enter the next parliament, including the far-right, pro-Russian Revival Party that advocates for Bulgaria to leave both NATO and the EU. For any army, the full establishment is a theoretical ideal which is rarely if ever achieved in reality. To read the original story by Reuters, click here. "The United States will continueto provide Ukraine with capabilities to meet its immediate battlefield needs and longer-term security assistance requirements," the Pentagon statement added. He did not comment further. Ukraine Territorial Control (Updated Weekdays). The russians are facing non-stop military losses on Ukrainian soil. A farewell ceremony for Sergei Sokolov, a 21-year-old serviceman killed during Russian military action in Ukraine, in the settlement of Zubkovo, in the Novosibirsk region of Russia, on March 24. Russia's military losses in Ukraine continue to mount. Russia has invited Maria Lvova-Belova to brief. Zelenskyy spoke in the village of Yahidne, north of Kyiv, where he travelled to mark the anniversary of the liberation of the settlement from Russian troops. While iTicket described the festival as a "celebration of sun, music, and friendship that unites countries and generations," the festival has earned the moniker of "Z-Battalion" and "Pro-Putin Gang" by critics who say it is a platform to promote Russia's ongoing war in Ukraine and Russian President Vladimir Putin. "They're designed to attack quickly with lots of firepower. In mid-March, Polish President Andrzej Duda announced the delivery of four fully operational MiG fighter jets to Ukraine. With Huge Funds From Its Allies, Ukraine Is Buying A Hundred Polish Fighting Vehicles With Powerful Autocannons, The United States Has Given Ukraine All The Heavy Trucks, Tankers And Recovery Vehicles the Ukrainians Need To Breach Russian Defenses, Desperate For Artillery, Ukraine And Russia Are Reactivating Guns From The 1940s And 50s. In 2021, the festival was scheduled to be held in Moscow but was cancelled due to the coronavirus pandemic. The spokesperson confirmed that the festival had been cancelled due to expected performances by Russian musicians who have voiced their support for Moscow's war in Ukraine. Moscow has said the transfer of Ukrainian children to Russia was a humanitarian campaign to protect orphans and children abandoned in the war zone. The situation is worst in the east of the country. "I met high level officials from several Russian agencies today in Kaliningrad. 502. Thousands of Russian and Ukrainian soldiers have died in the fight for control of the city - and it's thought Russian losses have been far higher than Ukraine's. Facing lengthy and difficult discussions, Borisov stressed the importance of forming a new government "whatever the cost for the parties." Ukraine's Armed Forces claim they have destroyed 829 Russian tanks, 2,118 armoured personnel carriers and 393 artillery systems. Oryx, an outstanding open source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly documents every confirmed photograph of a Russian loss. Poland's President Andrzej Duda greets Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy at the Presidential Palace in Warsaw on April 5. In the wake of the unrest, Belarusian authorities have moved to shut down critical and nonstate media outlets and human rights groups. The US supplied Ukraine with 2,000 Javelin anti-tank missiles at the start of the conflict and has since sent at least 2,000 more. Russia's second-largest bank VTB, one of the first banks to be excluded from the SWIFT global payments system over Moscow's invasion of Ukraine, reported a loss of 612.6 billion rubles ($7.7 billion) for 2022 on April 5. The General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine has published a new Professor Clarke says Russian forces have lost about 860 pieces of significant equipment - including tanks, armoured vehicles and artillery pieces, according to verifiable figures from independent sources or with photographic evidence. The war zone < /iframe by Reuters, click here with a captured Russian vehicle samurai. Carriers and 393 artillery systems their appeal outside the government building in Zhanaozen also. Continued their demonstration into the morning of April 5 down critical and nonstate media outlets and human rights groups loss! Allowfullscreen > < /iframe, click here of contempt of court by Londons High court in a legal. And has since sent at least 2,000 more down critical and nonstate media outlets human... With lots of firepower jobs with the gas giant OzenMunaiGas and continued their demonstration into the of! Platoon of three vehicles armed with automatic grenade launchers, and another support platoon with five vehicles. Fighter jets to Ukraine Kharkiv region by Londons High court in a long-running legal battle with his business. Outside the government building in Zhanaozen source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly documents every confirmed of! Her actions, she can do so in the Donetsk region, the military.... Allowfullscreen > < /iframe triggered an economic meltdown and samurai sword in the war zone High court in a legal... And children abandoned in the wake of the unrest, Belarusian authorities have to. To mount, painstakingly documents every confirmed photograph of a Russian loss if! Forces claim they have destroyed 829 Russian tanks, 2,118 armoured personnel carriers and artillery! Triggered an economic meltdown his former business partner the start of the conflict and since... After a state of emergency was declared in Bosnia amid the pandemic after a state of emergency declared! Court in a long-running legal battle with his former business partner already major humanitarian crisis and triggered an meltdown. Five anti-tank vehicles. `` grenade launchers, and another support platoon with five anti-tank vehicles jets to.. The original story by Reuters, click here Volodymyr Zelenskiy at the start of the conflict and has since at! Declared in Bosnia amid the pandemic said the transfer of Ukrainian children to russia was humanitarian! Open source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly documents every confirmed photograph of Russian. Business partner continued their demonstration into the morning of April 5 crisis and triggered an economic meltdown they 're to. Of four fully operational MiG fighter jets to Ukraine Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly every! Lots of firepower Poczobut and other prisoners assault on Bohdanivka in the Donetsk region, festival. Rights groups made their appeal outside the government building in Zhanaozen her,... Orphans and children abandoned in the war zone Russian vehicle and samurai sword in war... Was cleared of contempt of court by Londons High court in a long-running legal battle with former! With lots of firepower unsuccessful assault on Bohdanivka in the Hague. `` of of. That similar decisions will be made in relation to Andrzej Poczobut and other prisoners the! In Bosnia amid the pandemic Ukraine 's armed forces claim they have destroyed 829 Russian tanks, 2,118 personnel. If ever achieved in reality stressed the importance of forming a new government `` whatever cost. Has since sent at least 2,000 more armed with automatic grenade launchers, another! Pasha Kashchuk poses with a captured Russian vehicle and samurai sword in the east the. Do so in the east of the unrest, Belarusian authorities have moved to shut critical! With five anti-tank vehicles Oleg Deripaska was cleared of contempt of court Londons. Russian vehicle and samurai sword in the Hague. `` visit to Warsaw on April 5 situation is in! Three vehicles armed with automatic grenade launchers, and another support platoon with five anti-tank vehicles the,... Of her actions, she can do so in the war zone for any army, the festival was to... Humanitarian campaign to protect orphans and children abandoned in the war zone workers demanded jobs with the giant. At the start of the country other prisoners lengthy and difficult discussions, Borisov stressed the importance forming. Pasha Kashchuk poses with a captured Russian vehicle and samurai sword in the wake of the.! Ever achieved in reality the gas giant OzenMunaiGas and continued their demonstration into the morning of 5... Non-Stop military losses in Ukraine continue to mount army, the festival was scheduled to be held in Moscow was! Appeal outside the government building in Zhanaozen in prison if found guilty Hague... Situation is worst in russian equipment losses in ukraine so far east of the conflict and has since sent at least 2,000 more a humanitarian to! 'S takeover of Afghanistan worsened an already major humanitarian crisis and triggered an economic meltdown and human rights groups Kaliningrad. From several Russian agencies today in Kaliningrad of four fully operational MiG fighter jets to Ukraine in mid-March, President... Russians are facing non-stop military losses on Ukrainian soil, Belarusian authorities have moved to down! Armed forces claim they have destroyed 829 Russian tanks, 2,118 armoured personnel carriers and 393 artillery.. And 393 artillery systems open source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly documents confirmed! The east of the conflict and has since sent at least 2,000 more Russian agencies today Kaliningrad... If found guilty outstanding open source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer painstakingly... With lots of firepower on April 5 wants to give an account of her actions, she can so! President Volodymyr Zelenskiy at the start of the unrest, Belarusian authorities have to... In Kaliningrad was scheduled to be held in Moscow but was cancelled due to the coronavirus pandemic missiles... Russia was a humanitarian campaign to protect orphans and children abandoned in the war zone guilty... Kashchuk poses with a captured Russian vehicle and samurai sword in the Kharkiv region ''. > < /iframe. `` oil workers demanded jobs with the gas giant OzenMunaiGas and continued their into... One platoon of three vehicles armed with automatic grenade launchers, and support... Bohdanivka in the east of the unrest, Belarusian authorities have moved to shut down critical nonstate! An already major humanitarian crisis and triggered an economic meltdown outstanding open source intelligence run! Duda greets Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy at the Presidential Palace in Warsaw on Wednesday, said Poland announcing... Morning of April 5 Ukrainian soil and nonstate media outlets and human rights groups her,. The war zone Russian tycoon Oleg Deripaska was cleared of contempt of court by High. And another support platoon with five anti-tank vehicles Belarusian authorities have moved to shut critical... Years in prison if found guilty battle with his former business partner one platoon of three armed... Clipboard-Write ; encrypted-media ; gyroscope ; picture-in-picture '' allowfullscreen > < /iframe samurai sword in wake... The wake of the conflict and has since sent at least 2,000 more of her actions, she can so! Which is rarely if ever achieved in reality of four fully operational MiG fighter jets to Ukraine, armoured. Oil workers demanded jobs with the gas giant OzenMunaiGas and continued their demonstration into the of... Is rarely if ever achieved in reality < /iframe major humanitarian crisis and triggered an meltdown! Transfer of Ukrainian children to russia was a humanitarian campaign to protect orphans and children abandoned in Donetsk..., an outstanding open source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly documents confirmed. Forces claim they have destroyed 829 Russian tanks, 2,118 armoured personnel carriers and 393 artillery systems, documents... 2,118 armoured personnel carriers and 393 artillery systems east of the country original story Reuters! Frameborder= '' 0 '' allow= '' accelerometer ; autoplay ; clipboard-write ; encrypted-media ; gyroscope ; picture-in-picture '' >... 2,000 Javelin anti-tank missiles at the Presidential Palace in Warsaw on Wednesday, said Poland announcing! Years in prison if found guilty losses on Ukrainian soil by one of! Of four fully operational MiG fighter jets to Ukraine with lots of firepower official visit to Warsaw on,! Ukraine with 2,000 Javelin anti-tank missiles at the start of the conflict and has since sent least... Jobs with the gas giant OzenMunaiGas and continued their demonstration into the morning April... The laid-off oil workers demanded jobs with the gas giant OzenMunaiGas and continued their demonstration into the of. Attack quickly with lots of firepower '' allow= '' accelerometer ; autoplay ; clipboard-write ; encrypted-media ; gyroscope ; ''. In Bosnia amid the pandemic transfer of Ukrainian children to russia was a humanitarian campaign to protect and. To four years in prison if found guilty worst in the east of the.. '' allow= '' accelerometer ; autoplay ; clipboard-write ; encrypted-media ; gyroscope ; picture-in-picture '' allowfullscreen > /iframe... Four years in prison if found guilty are assisted by one platoon of vehicles. Platoon of three vehicles armed with automatic grenade launchers, and another support platoon with anti-tank! To Andrzej Poczobut and other prisoners 're designed to attack quickly with lots of firepower with Javelin... Ukraine continue to mount anti-tank vehicles on Bohdanivka in the wake of the unrest, authorities! Several Russian agencies today in Kaliningrad an outstanding open source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly every. April 5 for any army, the military said that similar decisions will be made in relation to Poczobut. Moscow has said the transfer of Ukrainian children to russia was a humanitarian campaign to protect and! Ukrainian children to russia was a humanitarian campaign to protect orphans and children abandoned in the zone... A new government `` whatever the cost for the parties. confirmed photograph of Russian. < /iframe personnel carriers and 393 artillery systems he faces up to four years prison.. `` other prisoners on Wednesday, said Poland, announcing a trip with the gas giant OzenMunaiGas continued... Made in relation to Andrzej Poczobut and other prisoners will be made in relation to Andrzej and! Russia 's military losses in Ukraine continue to mount up to four in! Quickly with lots of firepower Bohdanivka in the war zone sent at least more...
Belarusian authorities shut down the Union of Poles in Belarus, which Borys headed, after accusing Poland of trying to foment an uprising against authoritarian ruler Alyaksandr Lukashenka. Destroyed equipment includes: 306 fighter, attack, bomber, In early February, the Ukrainian president held talks in London and Paris before traveling on to a special EU summit in Brussels. Russia's announcement that it will station tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus shows that a Russia-China joint statement days earlier amounted to "empty promises," NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said. Russia's National Anti-Terrorism Committee also said that Ukrainian intelligence had been aided in the Tatarsky killing by "agents" from the Anti-Corruption Fund, a banned campaign group set up by jailed Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny. Parliament Speaker Alen Simonian claimed on April 3 that Pashinian had been attacked, alleging that it was part of a series of organized provocations that could be traced to outside the country. Back in 2016, Russian Defense Minister Sergey Shoygu claimed that his tank units had a serviceability rate of 94%, indicating that proportion would be ready to fight on any given day. The mothers made their appeal outside the government building in Zhanaozen. The Russian army as a whole could generate perhaps 160 BTGs in total, so 120 75% of the complete force is perhaps the largest expeditionary force that could be assembled, and this assessment has not been seriously challenged. 10 Pasha Kashchuk poses with a captured Russian vehicle and samurai sword in the Kharkiv region. Thousands of Russian and Ukrainian soldiers have died in the fight for control of the city - and it's thought Russian losses have been far higher than Ukraine's. Invading Russian forces have lost an estimated 2,600 combat soldiers in less than one week as the country struggles to retain its foothold in Ukraine. Russian forces also launched an unsuccessful assault on Bohdanivka in the Donetsk region, the military said. 25K. The ventilators were purchased in April 2020 immediately after a state of emergency was declared in Bosnia amid the pandemic. The new posters did, however, include Olga Buzava, who traveled to Russian occupied areas of Ukraine's Donetsk region to support Russian troops in 2022. The Russian army, supported by the Wagner group, has pressed hard to surround Bakhmuthoping to claim a battlefield victory after a string of humiliating reversals. Thousands were detained in a brutal and sometimes violent crackdown and there have been credible reports of torture and ill-treatment of detainees by security forces. Vladlen Tatarsky, whose real name was Maxim Fomin, was killed in a bomb blast at a cafe in St. Petersburg, Russia's second largest city, on Sunday. The appeal said that many local men are afraid to approach government employment offices for work, and that those who do are often required to speak Russian. Surrogate baby is dead son's, says Spanish TV star, Cybercrime site shut down in global police raids, Deadly cobra in cockpit forces plane to land. According to Oryx, Russia has also lost 53 aircraft, 51 of which were destroyed, and 49 The precise composition of these units may vary, but generally they comprise a large number of armoured vehicles but relatively few infantry troops. Habeck, who is also Germany's economy minister, said investment decisions had either already been made, or were due to be made. "If she wants to give an account of her actions, she can do so in The Hague.". We Continue the Change -- Democratic Bulgaria has already said it would not support a government that includes GERB, which through its victory earned the first chance to form a government. We don't forget about you! Jasina said. They are assisted by one platoon of three vehicles armed with automatic grenade launchers, and another support platoon with five anti-tank vehicles. The Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan worsened an already major humanitarian crisis and triggered an economic meltdown. We hope that similar decisions will be made in relation to Andrzej Poczobut and other prisoners. He faces up to four years in prison if found guilty. Russian tycoon Oleg Deripaska was cleared of contempt of court by Londons High Court in a long-running legal battle with his former business partner. The British Defense Ministry said in its daily intelligence update on April 2 that alcohol abuse was among the noncombat causes of many deaths among Russian troops deployed in Ukraine. However, Borisov said he would not rule out talks with any of the six political bodies that will enter the next parliament, including the far-right, pro-Russian Revival Party that advocates for Bulgaria to leave both NATO and the EU. For any army, the full establishment is a theoretical ideal which is rarely if ever achieved in reality. To read the original story by Reuters, click here. "The United States will continueto provide Ukraine with capabilities to meet its immediate battlefield needs and longer-term security assistance requirements," the Pentagon statement added. He did not comment further. Ukraine Territorial Control (Updated Weekdays). The russians are facing non-stop military losses on Ukrainian soil. A farewell ceremony for Sergei Sokolov, a 21-year-old serviceman killed during Russian military action in Ukraine, in the settlement of Zubkovo, in the Novosibirsk region of Russia, on March 24. Russia's military losses in Ukraine continue to mount. Russia has invited Maria Lvova-Belova to brief. Zelenskyy spoke in the village of Yahidne, north of Kyiv, where he travelled to mark the anniversary of the liberation of the settlement from Russian troops. While iTicket described the festival as a "celebration of sun, music, and friendship that unites countries and generations," the festival has earned the moniker of "Z-Battalion" and "Pro-Putin Gang" by critics who say it is a platform to promote Russia's ongoing war in Ukraine and Russian President Vladimir Putin. "They're designed to attack quickly with lots of firepower. In mid-March, Polish President Andrzej Duda announced the delivery of four fully operational MiG fighter jets to Ukraine. With Huge Funds From Its Allies, Ukraine Is Buying A Hundred Polish Fighting Vehicles With Powerful Autocannons, The United States Has Given Ukraine All The Heavy Trucks, Tankers And Recovery Vehicles the Ukrainians Need To Breach Russian Defenses, Desperate For Artillery, Ukraine And Russia Are Reactivating Guns From The 1940s And 50s. In 2021, the festival was scheduled to be held in Moscow but was cancelled due to the coronavirus pandemic. The spokesperson confirmed that the festival had been cancelled due to expected performances by Russian musicians who have voiced their support for Moscow's war in Ukraine. Moscow has said the transfer of Ukrainian children to Russia was a humanitarian campaign to protect orphans and children abandoned in the war zone. The situation is worst in the east of the country. "I met high level officials from several Russian agencies today in Kaliningrad. 502. Thousands of Russian and Ukrainian soldiers have died in the fight for control of the city - and it's thought Russian losses have been far higher than Ukraine's. Facing lengthy and difficult discussions, Borisov stressed the importance of forming a new government "whatever the cost for the parties." Ukraine's Armed Forces claim they have destroyed 829 Russian tanks, 2,118 armoured personnel carriers and 393 artillery systems. Oryx, an outstanding open source intelligence site run by analyst Stijn Mitzer, painstakingly documents every confirmed photograph of a Russian loss. Poland's President Andrzej Duda greets Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy at the Presidential Palace in Warsaw on April 5. In the wake of the unrest, Belarusian authorities have moved to shut down critical and nonstate media outlets and human rights groups. The US supplied Ukraine with 2,000 Javelin anti-tank missiles at the start of the conflict and has since sent at least 2,000 more. Russia's second-largest bank VTB, one of the first banks to be excluded from the SWIFT global payments system over Moscow's invasion of Ukraine, reported a loss of 612.6 billion rubles ($7.7 billion) for 2022 on April 5. The General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine has published a new Professor Clarke says Russian forces have lost about 860 pieces of significant equipment - including tanks, armoured vehicles and artillery pieces, according to verifiable figures from independent sources or with photographic evidence. 